Carl How to play Carl
Carl counters
The best counters to Carl right now are Vince (66.5%), Cosmo (63.0%), Gus (62.7%): the share of head-to-head games each one wins against Carl, from 858 ranked and high-trophy games.
Who beats Carl
Carl vs popular picks
- ShadeCarl wins 46.5%472 games

- WendyCarl wins 43.8%311 games

- RicoCarl wins 47.4%445 games

- MaxCarl wins 43.3%213 games

- BrockCarl wins 52.2%342 games

- PiperCarl wins 48.3%194 games

How to beat Carl
- Punish him while the pickaxe is in the air. He cannot attack until it comes back.
- Fight at max range. Long throws return slowly, which cuts his damage.
- Use walls. His pickaxe stops on cover and returns early.
Common mistake: Standing in the path of the pickaxe on its way back. It hits on the return too.
Best Carl Build
Star Powers
Gadgets
Recommended Gears
Hypercharge
Game plan
Carl throws a pickaxe that flies out and comes back like a boomerang, damaging everyone it passes through both ways. He only has one ammo, which returns with the pickaxe, so his attack rate depends on distance. His Super is a fast spin that damages everything he touches.
- Fight closer than max range. A shorter throw returns sooner, so your pickaxe hits more often up close.
- Throw so the return path also crosses enemies. Two hits per throw is how Carl deals his damage.
- Use your Super to chase low targets or to escape, since it doubles your speed.
Drafting Carl
- When to pick
- Pick Carl on mid-range maps in Gem Grab, Heist and Hot Zone.
- Who to pair with
- Pair him with a controller or support who keeps the fight at his preferred range.
- Ban or not
- Rarely worth a ban. Long-range brawlers who out-trade him at max range are the cleaner answer.
Best teammates
Win rate by mode
Brawl Ball54.1%308 games
Heist51.4%116 games
Adjusted win rate: results are pulled toward 50% when a mode has few games, so the overall figure can sit above every single mode.
Frequently asked Questions
Is Carl good in Brawl Stars?
Carl is B-tier on the BrawlUp tier list right now, with a 58.5% win rate over 838 recent ranked and high-trophy games.
What is the best build for Carl?
Run Power Throw as the Star Power and Flying Hook as the Gadget, with Shield and Speed gears.
What counters Carl?
Carl has the hardest time against Vince, Cosmo, Gus, based on head-to-head win rates.
What game modes is Carl best in?
Carl wins most in Brawl Ball (54.1%).
Who are the best teammates for Carl?
Amber, Gray, Max have the highest win rate alongside Carl.
How do you play Carl in Brawl Stars?
Carl throws a pickaxe that flies out and comes back like a boomerang, damaging everyone it passes through both ways. He only has one ammo, which returns with the pickaxe, so his attack rate depends on distance. His Super is a fast spin that damages everything he touches.
Win rates come from ranked and high-trophy battles collected by BrawlUp and are adjusted toward 50% when the sample is small. Updated 2026-10-27. How we calculate this