Eight brawlers sit in S tier on November 15, 2026, up from five at the start of the month. Vince is still first at 95, and six of the other seven got a Buffie in the November 2 update.
This is the mid-month update of the November report. The tier list now covers the 14 days from November 1 to 15 (119,144 games), so both the November 2 balance patch and the November 11 maintenance are inside the window, the second one with only four days of data behind it.
The Buffie brawlers took over. Mr. P, Gale, Lou, Mandy, Chester and Berry all reached S tier within two weeks of getting their Buffies, and Brock joined them from A. Vince is still first, but his Meta Index slipped from 100 to 95 and he now appears in about one game in thirteen instead of one in nine.
Supercell answered on November 11 with nerfs to Vince, Mr. P, Gale, Lou, Chester, Mandy, Amber and Wendy. In our tracked battles, which win well above 50% overall (67.5% from November 4 to 10, 67.0% from November 12 to 15), Mr. P fell from 78.1% to 72.1% (2,798 to 837 games) and Lou from 74.9% to 71.4% (2,277 to 811), far more than the half-point baseline dip. Vince lost about one point (5,081 to 1,942 games), while Chester and Mandy actually won slightly more after their changes. Four days is a short sample, so treat this as a first read.
Berry and Chester made the biggest jumps, both from C to S, and Chester did it in a single week after bouncing between B and C. Gale, Lou and Mr. P went from B to S, Melodie climbed from C to A on the back of Heist, and Meg is finally out of F.
Kit had the hardest fall, from A to F, with no balance change to blame. Amber, Gus and Shade all dropped from S to B, El Primo and Lily slid to C, and Cosmo, first on the list in October, is now in A.
Vince still owns Brawl Ball, Knockout and Gem Grab, but he lost three modes since the start of the month: Gale now leads Hot Zone, Mr. P leads Bounty and Melodie leads Heist, ahead of Colette and Colt.
8-Bit is the surprise of the duo board: he appears in three of the five strongest pairs, with Nani at 80.9% over 1,335 games. Tick is still the brawler the meta punishes most, losing to Lou in 92.0% of 1,767 games.
Strongest duos
8-Bit + Nani1,335 games80.9%
Gale + Lou2,049 games79.5%
8-Bit + Doug699 games78.1%
8-Bit + Bo924 games77.5%
Chester + Lou2,240 games77.5%
Most one-sided matchups
VSLou beats Tick1,767 games92.0%
VSGale beats Tick1,616 games90.9%
VSChester beats Tick1,618 games89.5%
VSAmber beats Tick1,427 games89.1%
VSMandy beats Tick3,250 games86.9%
Draft plan
Vince is still the first ban. Even after the November 11 nerf he leads three modes and is the most played brawler in the sample.
Ban by mode, not by habit. Gale in Hot Zone, Mr. P in Bounty and Melodie in Heist are now the picks to take away.
Gale and Lou together are a trap to leave open. The pair wins 79.5% of 2,049 games, so if one goes, take or ban the other.
Keep Tick on the bench. Every one of the five most one-sided matchups has him on the losing end.
Previous months
October 2026Cosmo was first on the tier list every day from October 10 to 19, peaking at 100. Amber climbed from A to S despite her September nerfs, while Alli fell from S to B and Kenji from S to A. There was no balance patch that month, so every move came from players adapting.
Data from BrawlUp's sample of ranked and high-trophy battles, last 14 days to November 15, 2026. Win rates are adjusted toward 50% when a sample is small. Methodology
Every one of the strongest duos with at least 300 games includes Vince except Amber and Maisie. On the other side, Tick is on the losing end of the five most one-sided matchups.
Strongest duos
Cosmo + Vince1,027 games82.3%
Vince + Wendy1,043 games81.2%
Amber + Vince1,227 games78.5%
Starr Nova + Vince506 games75.5%
Amber + Maisie830 games75.0%
Most one-sided matchups
VSAmber beats Tick1,807 games89.7%
VSGus beats Tick1,505 games85.7%
VSMax beats Tick768 games85.0%
VSMaisie beats Tick464 games83.4%
VSVince beats Tick885 games82.3%
Draft plan
Ban Vince or plan for him. He is the top pick in five of six modes. If he is left open, first-pick him yourself.
Do not ban Shade by habit. His third nerf in a row is already pulling him down; Cosmo and Mr. P are better second bans.
Learn the Buffie brawlers. Mr. P, Gale, Lou, Chester, Mandy and Berry are in a large share of lobbies right now, even while their win rates settle.
In Heist, think Nori, Shade or Carl. It is the one mode where Vince is not the answer.
Previous months
October 2026Cosmo was first on the tier list every day from October 10 to 19, peaking at 100. Amber climbed from A to S despite her September nerfs, while Alli fell from S to B and Kenji from S to A. There was no balance patch that month, so every move came from players adapting.
Data from BrawlUp's sample of ranked and high-trophy battles, last 14 days to November 6, 2026. Win rates are adjusted toward 50% when a sample is small. Methodology
Every one of the strongest duos with at least 300 games includes Vince except Amber and Maisie. On the other side, Tick is on the losing end of the five most one-sided matchups.
Strongest duos
Cosmo + Vince1,027 games82.3%
Vince + Wendy1,043 games81.2%
Amber + Vince1,227 games78.5%
Starr Nova + Vince506 games75.5%
Amber + Maisie830 games75.0%
Most one-sided matchups
VSAmber beats Tick1,807 games89.7%
VSGus beats Tick1,505 games85.7%
VSMax beats Tick768 games85.0%
VSMaisie beats Tick464 games83.4%
VSVince beats Tick885 games82.3%
Draft plan
Ban Vince or plan for him. He is the top pick in five of six modes. If he is left open, first-pick him yourself.
Do not ban Shade by habit. His third nerf in a row is already pulling him down; Cosmo and Mr. P are better second bans.
Learn the Buffie brawlers. Mr. P, Gale, Lou, Chester, Mandy and Berry are in a large share of lobbies right now, even while their win rates settle.
In Heist, think Nori, Shade or Carl. It is the one mode where Vince is not the answer.
Previous months
October 2026Cosmo was first on the tier list every day from October 10 to 19, peaking at 100. Amber climbed from A to S despite her September nerfs, while Alli fell from S to B and Kenji from S to A. There was no balance patch that month, so every move came from players adapting.
Data from BrawlUp's sample of ranked and high-trophy battles, last 14 days to November 6, 2026. Win rates are adjusted toward 50% when a sample is small. Methodology
Every one of the strongest duos with at least 300 games includes Vince except Amber and Maisie. On the other side, Tick is on the losing end of the five most one-sided matchups.
Strongest duos
Cosmo + Vince1,027 games82.3%
Vince + Wendy1,043 games81.2%
Amber + Vince1,227 games78.5%
Starr Nova + Vince506 games75.5%
Amber + Maisie830 games75.0%
Most one-sided matchups
VSAmber > Tick1,807 games89.7%
VSGus > Tick1,505 games85.7%
VSMax > Tick768 games85.0%
VSMaisie > Tick464 games83.4%
VSVince > Tick885 games82.3%
Draft plan
Ban Vince or plan for him. He is the top pick in five of six modes. If he is left open, first-pick him yourself.
Do not ban Shade by habit. His third nerf in a row is already pulling him down; Cosmo and Mr. P are better second bans.
Learn the Buffie brawlers. Mr. P, Gale, Lou, Chester, Mandy and Berry are in a large share of lobbies right now, even while their win rates settle.
In Heist, think Nori, Shade or Carl. It is the one mode where Vince is not the answer.
Previous months
October 2026Cosmo was first on the tier list every day from October 10 to 19, peaking at 100. Amber climbed from A to S despite her September nerfs, while Alli fell from S to B and Kenji from S to A. There was no balance patch that month, so every move came from players adapting.
Data from BrawlUp's sample of ranked and high-trophy battles, last 14 days to November 6, 2026. Win rates are adjusted toward 50% when a sample is small. Methodology
Every one of the strongest duos with at least 300 games includes Vince except Amber and Maisie. On the other side, Tick is on the losing end of the five most one-sided matchups.
Strongest duos
Cosmo + Vince1,027 games82.3%
Vince + Wendy1,043 games81.2%
Amber + Vince1,227 games78.5%
Starr Nova + Vince506 games75.5%
Amber + Maisie830 games75.0%
Most one-sided matchups
VSAmber > Tick1,807 games89.7%
VSGus > Tick1,505 games85.7%
VSMax > Tick768 games85.0%
VSMaisie > Tick464 games83.4%
VSVince > Tick885 games82.3%
Draft plan
Ban Vince or plan for him. He is the top pick in five of six modes. If he is left open, first-pick him yourself.
Do not ban Shade by habit. His third nerf in a row is already pulling him down; Cosmo and Mr. P are better second bans.
Learn the Buffie brawlers. Mr. P, Gale, Lou, Chester, Mandy and Berry are in a large share of lobbies right now, even while their win rates settle.
In Heist, think Nori, Shade or Carl. It is the one mode where Vince is not the answer.
Previous months
October 2026Cosmo was first on the tier list every day from October 10 to 19, peaking at 100. Amber climbed from A to S despite her September nerfs, while Alli fell from S to B and Kenji from S to A. There was no balance patch that month, so every move came from players adapting.
Data from BrawlUp's sample of ranked and high-trophy battles, last 14 days to November 6, 2026. Win rates are adjusted toward 50% when a sample is small. Methodology
Every one of the strongest duos with at least 300 games includes Vince except Amber and Maisie. On the other side, Tick is on the losing end of the five most one-sided matchups.
Strongest duos
Cosmo + Vince1,027 games82.3%
Vince + Wendy1,043 games81.2%
Amber + Vince1,227 games78.5%
Starr Nova + Vince506 games75.5%
Amber + Maisie830 games75.0%
Most one-sided matchups
VSAmber > Tick1,807 games89.7%
VSGus > Tick1,505 games85.7%
VSMax > Tick768 games85.0%
VSMaisie > Tick464 games83.4%
VSVince > Tick885 games82.3%
Draft plan
Ban Vince or plan for him. He is the top pick in five of six modes. If he is left open, first-pick him yourself.
Do not ban Shade by habit. His third nerf in a row is already pulling him down; Cosmo and Mr. P are better second bans.
Learn the Buffie brawlers. Mr. P, Gale, Lou, Chester, Mandy and Berry are in a large share of lobbies right now, even while their win rates settle.
In Heist, think Nori, Shade or Carl. It is the one mode where Vince is not the answer.
Previous months
October 2026Cosmo was first on the tier list every day from October 10 to 19, peaking at 100. Amber climbed from A to S despite her September nerfs, while Alli fell from S to B and Kenji from S to A. There was no balance patch that month, so every move came from players adapting.
Data from BrawlUp's sample of ranked and high-trophy battles, last 14 days to November 6, 2026. Win rates are adjusted toward 50% when a sample is small. Methodology
Every one of the strongest duos with at least 300 games includes Vince except Amber and Maisie. On the other side, Tick is on the losing end of the five most one-sided matchups.
Strongest duos
Cosmo + Vince1,027 games82.3%
Vince + Wendy1,043 games81.2%
Amber + Vince1,227 games78.5%
Starr Nova + Vince506 games75.5%
Amber + Maisie830 games75.0%
Most one-sided matchups
Amber beats Tick1,807 games89.7%
Gus beats Tick1,505 games85.7%
Max beats Tick768 games85.0%
Maisie beats Tick464 games83.4%
Vince beats Tick885 games82.3%
Draft plan
Ban Vince or plan for him. He is the top pick in five of six modes. If he is left open, first-pick him yourself.
Do not ban Shade by habit. His third nerf in a row is already pulling him down; Cosmo and Mr. P are better second bans.
Learn the Buffie brawlers. Mr. P, Gale, Lou, Chester, Mandy and Berry are in a large share of lobbies right now, even while their win rates settle.
In Heist, think Nori, Shade or Carl. It is the one mode where Vince is not the answer.
Previous months
October 2026Cosmo was first on the tier list every day from October 10 to 19, peaking at 100. Amber climbed from A to S despite her September nerfs, while Alli fell from S to B and Kenji from S to A. There was no balance patch that month, so every move came from players adapting.
Data from BrawlUp's sample of ranked and high-trophy battles, last 14 days to November 6, 2026. Win rates are adjusted toward 50% when a sample is small. Methodology